Town of Shelter Island Building Department
38 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Phone: (631) 749-0772
Official page
Where this code applies
All of Shelter Island, including Shelter Island Heights and Dering Harbor's surroundings (Dering Harbor is its own village).
What the Town of Shelter Island pool code requires
What counts as a pool here: An enclosed container of water more than 10 feet long and 24 inches or more deep, built for swimming or therapy.
Permit and plans
- A Building Inspector permit is required to install or reconstruct a pool (any repair, maintenance or renovation over $5,000 counts) and to fill or refill a freshwater pool.
- The application includes a survey certified by a licensed engineer (at least 1 inch = 40 feet) showing the pool, deck, equipment and fencing and their distances to every building, well, septic system and dry well, including the neighbors'. It also needs a water management plan (filter, pumps, heater, water source, backflow), a runoff and sediment control plan, and any other agency permits.
- Applications to fill or refill must name the water supplier, and the water receipt must be given to the Building Inspector before the certificate of occupancy.
Where the pool can go
- Pool equipment (pumps, filters, heaters) must meet the setbacks in Chapter 133.
- Excavation must stay above the water table; no dewatering is allowed.
Fence and barrier
- A temporary fence around the excavation from the day work starts, and a permanent fence within 90 days of the start of excavation.
- A driveway gate counts as part of the pool barrier only if it's self-latching.
Pool water and drainage
- Effluent dry wells at least 8 by 8 feet (or equivalent linked dry wells), at least 2 feet above the water table, vented or grated, at least 50 feet from drinking-water wells, 75 feet from surface waters and wetlands, and 20 feet from any septic system, including the neighbors'.
- Freshwater pools must be filled and refilled from an off-island water supply.
- Pool water can't go into marine or fresh waters, wetlands, a bluff, a neighbor's property, a road, a sewer or a septic system. Don't drain more than 2 feet below the skimmer except for repairs. Neutralize acids before disposal.
Alarms, covers, equipment and neighbors
- Pool service staff must be certified at least at NSPI Tech 1.
- Drowning protection: either a powered safety cover meeting ASTM F1346, or alarms on every door with direct access to the pool.
Removing or abandoning a pool
- Abandoned pools are prohibited: they must be removed right away and the pit filled with clean upland sand topped with at least 6 inches of topsoil for replanting.
Summarized from Town Code Ch. 113 (Swimming Pools). Checked November 2026. Codes change, so confirm with the Town of Shelter Island building department before work starts.
What the Shelter Island code means on a real job
Shelter Island's code protects one thing above all: the island's groundwater. Freshwater pools must be filled from an off-island supply, with the water receipt given to the Building Inspector. Excavation must stay above the water table, with no dewatering, which on the island's till soils can cap how deep a pool can go. A spring test pit at the pool site settles it.
The survey is also heavier than anywhere else: certified by a licensed engineer at 1 inch = 40 feet or larger, showing every nearby well, septic system and dry well, the neighbors' included. Dry wells must be 8 by 8 feet, 50 feet from drinking-water wells and 75 feet from wetlands. Abandoned pools aren't allowed: an unused pool must be removed and the pit filled. Details for owners are on the Shelter Island town page.
Ground conditions in the Town of Shelter Island towns on this site
| Place | Main soil | 8%+ slopes | Water table within ~3 ft | FEMA flood zone | Water supplier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter Island | Montauk loam (3–8% slopes) | 26% | 52% | 16% | private wells |
Compare: fence rules by town · every Suffolk County office
Town of Shelter Island pool permit questions
Do I need a permit for a pool in the Town of Shelter Island?
Yes. A Building Inspector permit is required to install or reconstruct a pool (any repair, maintenance or renovation over $5,000 counts) and to fill or refill a freshwater pool.
How close to the property line can a pool be in the Town of Shelter Island?
Pool equipment (pumps, filters, heaters) must meet the setbacks in Chapter 133.
How high does a pool fence have to be in the Town of Shelter Island?
A temporary fence around the excavation from the day work starts, and a permanent fence within 90 days of the start of excavation.
Where can pool water be drained in the Town of Shelter Island?
Effluent dry wells at least 8 by 8 feet (or equivalent linked dry wells), at least 2 feet above the water table, vented or grated, at least 50 feet from drinking-water wells, 75 feet from surface waters and wetlands, and 20 feet from any septic system, including the neighbors'.
What does the Town of Shelter Island require when you remove a pool?
Abandoned pools are prohibited: they must be removed right away and the pit filled with clean upland sand topped with at least 6 inches of topsoil for replanting.
What else does the Town of Shelter Island code require for a pool?
Pool service staff must be certified at least at NSPI Tech 1. Drowning protection: either a powered safety cover meeting ASTM F1346, or alarms on every door with direct access to the pool.