Why East End pools take more planning
The East End's codes are written around groundwater, wetlands and neighbors' quiet. In the Town of East Hampton, a licensed surveyor stakes the pool before a permit is issued, every pool needs dry wells, and filtration runs off-peak. The Town of Southampton sets pump types by pool size (variable speed at 800 square feet and up) and waives the permit fee for solar pool heaters. The Village of Southampton bans right-angle elbows in pool plumbing.
On the North Fork, the Town of Southold sends any work within 100 feet of a wetland or bluff to its Board of Trustees, and new patios must hold a 2-inch rainfall on site. Riverhead requires a pump-out and a 4-by-4-foot dry well near wetlands. Shelter Island requires off-island fill water, no dewatering, and immediate removal of abandoned pools.
Southampton Village's median home value: $2 million or more (the Census top-codes values above this).
Town guides, roomiest lots first
| Town | Homes per sq mi | Median home value | 8%+ slopes | Water table within ~3 ft | FEMA flood zone | Pool rules from |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Westhampton | 179 | about $1,018,000 | 1% | 2% | 9% | Town of Southampton |
| Montauk | 248 | about $1,357,000 | 35% | 59% | 11% | Town of East Hampton |
| Mattituck | 271 | about $750,000 | 14% | 6% | 9% | Town of Southold |
| Shelter Island | 282 | about $1,104,000 | 26% | 52% | 16% | Town of Shelter Island |
| Southold | 380 | about $845,000 | 8% | 14% | 19% | Town of Southold |
| Riverhead | 383 | about $457,000 | 4% | 7% | 2% | Town of Riverhead |
| East Hampton | 391 | $2 million or more (the Census top-codes values above this) | 1% | 9% | 19% | Village of East Hampton |
| Southampton | 592 | $2 million or more (the Census top-codes values above this) | 0% | 11% | 20% | Village of Southampton |
| Hampton Bays | 680 | about $735,000 | 11% | 6% | 11% | Town of Southampton |
Frequently asked questions
Do Hamptons towns have special pool rules?
Yes. The Town of East Hampton doubles the normal accessory-structure setback for a pool, its deck and its equipment, requires dry wells and a surveyor's stake-out, encloses pumps on all four sides for noise, and limits filtration to off-peak hours. The Town of Southampton requires pool equipment 10 feet from all property lines with screening and noise control, plus pump and pipe-size rules.
Can I fill a pool from my well on Shelter Island?
No. Shelter Island's code requires freshwater pools to be filled and refilled from an off-island water supply, and you give the water receipt to the Building Inspector before the certificate of occupancy.
How far from the water does a pool have to be on the North Fork?
In the Town of Southold, a pool and its related structures must be at least 60 feet from a wetland boundary (100 feet if it needs retaining walls more than 2 feet above grade) and 100 feet from the top of a bluff, and work within 100 feet of these areas needs a Board of Trustees permit.
Are pools more expensive on the East End?
We didn't find published price lists that differ by area. One builder's published gunite range on Long Island runs up to $250,000, and East End codes add items (dry wells, enclosed equipment, surveyor staking) that other towns don't require.
Sources
- Town of East Hampton Code § 255-11-89, Swimming pools
- Town of Southampton Code Ch. 123 Art. VI, Swimming Pools
- Town of Southampton Code § 330-77, accessory placement
- Town of Southold Code § 275-3, setbacks
- Town of Shelter Island Code Ch. 113, Swimming Pools
- Town of Riverhead Code § 301-230, Swimming pools
- U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024 5-year: Southampton village housing tables