Remove, repair or leave it?
A pool helps some sales and hurts others. Before deciding, price all three:
| Option | Published Long Island price |
|---|---|
| New vinyl liner | $4,000 – $7,500 |
| Resurface a gunite pool | $6,000 – $15,000 |
| Fill-in (vinyl) | $5,000 – $11,000 |
| Fill-in (gunite or fiberglass) | $7,000 – $14,000 |
| Full removal | $10,000 – $25,000 |
Fill-in or full removal?
A fill-in breaks down the top of the walls, punches drainage holes in the floor and fills the hole. It’s cheaper, but the broken shell stays buried, which can limit building on that spot later. A full removal hauls the shell away and backfills with clean fill. For a sale, a full removal with compaction records gives buyers the least to worry about.
Your town’s rules come with you to closing
| Office | Removal rule |
|---|---|
| Town of Babylon | Demolition permit required to restore the grade |
| Town of Islip | Restore the grade, notify the Building Inspector, get the applicable permits |
| Town of Brookhaven | Fill, restore the grade, notify the Chief Building Inspector |
| Town of North Hempstead | Restore the grade, notify the Building Department; the permit record is marked |
| Town of Riverhead | Notify the Zoning Officer before and after |
| Village of Massapequa Park | Pool fence down within 60 days unless approved to stay |
Keep the permit, the inspection sign-off and the contractor’s invoice describing the method. Buyers’ attorneys ask for them.
More: pool removal · pool removal cost on Long Island.
Need it done? Call for pool removal & fill-in on Long Island. Local guides: pools in Levittown, pools in Massapequa, pools in Bay Shore.
Frequently asked questions
Does a filled-in pool have to be disclosed when selling?
Ask your attorney about disclosure. What matters to buyers is whether the shell is still in the ground and whether the town signed off. A full removal with the permit and the town's final sign-off is the simplest story to tell.
Is it worth fixing a pool instead of removing it before a sale?
Compare the costs. A new liner runs $4,000 – $7,500 and resurfacing $6,000 – $15,000 on published Long Island prices, versus $10,000 – $25,000 for a full removal. A working, code-compliant pool is a feature; a failing one is a negotiation point.
What happens to the pool fence after removal?
In the Village of Massapequa Park, the pool fence must come down within 60 days unless you apply to keep it. Elsewhere, ask the building department; a buyer may want the fence for a dog or privacy.