Bay Shore site check: homes, soil, flood zones and water
| Bay Shore | Here | Suffolk County |
|---|---|---|
| Single-family detached homes | about 54% | about 80% |
| Owner-occupied | about 63% | about 82% |
| Median home value | about $492,000 | about $578,000 |
| Built before 1960 | about 43% | about 31% |
| Homes per square mile | 1,814 | – |
| Most common soil | Riverhead and Haven soils, graded (0–8% slopes): regraded loam over sand and gravel (42% of land) | |
| Land on 8%+ slopes | 0% | |
| Soil with a seasonal water table within ~3 ft | 2% (17% is pavement or fill the survey doesn't rate) | |
| Land in a FEMA flood zone | 8% (AE 8%) | |
| Public water supplier | Suffolk County Water Authority (100%) | |
| Pool permits from | Town of Islip Building Division (Department of Planning & Development), (631) 224-5466 | |
Bay Shore’s housing
Bay Shore is more varied than most South Shore hamlets: about 54% single-family detached and about 63% owner-occupied, with a median build year of 1965 and roughly 1,814 homes per square mile of land (Census ACS 2020–2024 and the 2024 Gazetteer). The median value is around $492,000.
Your zoning district sets the setback
The Town of Islip is one of the few Long Island towns that ties pool setbacks to the zoning district:
| District | Minimum side and rear setback |
|---|---|
| Residence AAA and AA | 18 ft |
| Residence A | 14 ft |
| Residence BAA | 25 ft |
| All other districts | 10 ft |
Distances are measured from the outside edge of an inground pool. Pool equipment needs 6 feet from the side and rear lines. Your survey or the town’s zoning map tells you which district you’re in.
The fence, Islip-style
- At least 4 feet from the pool’s outermost edge, and between 4 and 6 feet tall.
- Stockade rails facing in, no projections a child could climb.
- Temporary barrier during construction; permanent barrier within 90 days; no water until it’s up.
- Self-closing, self-latching gates, locked when the pool is unattended; ladders and diving boards inside the enclosure.
Paperwork that protects you
The Town of Islip code says no one may install a pool for an owner without first getting a copy of the permit, and it must be displayed on site while work is done. Fines run up to $5,000 per violation, and each day counts separately. When the pool is finished, you get a Certificate of Compliance. Published Long Island prices: vinyl $35,000 – $100,000.
Bay Shore’s ground and flood zones
Bay Shore is flat: none of our sample points fell on slopes of 8% or more. The USDA maps about 42% of the hamlet as graded Riverhead and Haven soils and 11% as Riverhead sandy loam, both well drained, plus about 12% pavement and 9% cut and fill. About 8% of the land is in a FEMA AE flood zone south of Montauk Highway near the bay, with base flood elevations of 4 to 7 feet in the mapped areas.
For most Bay Shore lots north of the highway, the dig is routine and the zoning district’s setback (10 to 25 feet in the Town of Islip) is what decides the pool’s size. For lots near the water, ask for groundwater control in the quote and keep the equipment above the flood elevation. Bay Shore also has more renters and multi-family housing than most hamlets on this site (about 54% single-family detached, about 62% owner-occupied), so check that the lot is zoned for a single-family accessory pool before you design one. Water comes from the Suffolk County Water Authority across the hamlet.
| Soil | Share of land | What it is | Seasonal water table |
|---|---|---|---|
| Riverhead and Haven soils, graded (0–8% slopes) | 42% | regraded loam over sand and gravel | deeper or not rated |
| Urban land | 12% | pavement and buildings; not rated by the survey | deeper or not rated |
| Riverhead sandy loam (0–3% slopes) | 11% | deep, well-drained sandy loam over sand and gravel | deeper or not rated |
| Cut and fill land, gently sloping | 9% | regraded or filled ground; ask for a soil check | deeper or not rated |
Guides for Bay Shore homeowners
Bay Shore pool questions
How far from the property line does a pool have to be in Bay Shore?
It depends on the zoning district: 10 feet in most districts, 14 feet in Residence A, 18 feet in Residence AA and AAA, and 25 feet in Residence BAA, measured from the outside edge of an inground pool. Pool equipment needs 6 feet.
How long do I have to put up the permanent pool fence in Bay Shore?
The Town of Islip gives 90 days from the permit's issue or the start of construction, whichever applies, with extensions for good cause such as weather. A temporary barrier is required in the meantime, and no water goes in the pool until the barrier is up.
Is Brightwaters under Islip's pool rules?
No. Brightwaters, next to Bay Shore, is an incorporated village with its own building department.
How much of Bay Shore is in a FEMA flood zone?
About 8% of the hamlet's land in our sample, all AE with base flood elevations of 4 to 7 feet, near the bay. If your lot is one of them, the equipment pad has to sit above the flood elevation the permit sets.
Sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024 5-year: Bay Shore and Suffolk County housing tables
- USDA NRCS, Soil Survey Geographic Database (SSURGO) via Soil Data Access
- USDA NRCS Web Soil Survey (look up your own lot)
- FEMA Flood Map Service Center, National Flood Hazard Layer
- U.S. EPA, Community Water System Service Area Boundaries
- Town of Islip Code Art. XXVIII, Swimming Pools (eCode360)
- Town of Islip Building Division