Suffolk County · Town of Smithtown

Pool installation in Commack, NY: two towns' rules and costs

Commack site check: homes, soil, flood zones and water

Commack (Census-designated place) vs. Suffolk County. Housing: Census ACS 2020–2024 5-year. Land shares: our grid sample of USDA, FEMA and EPA maps over the town boundary, November 2026.
CommackHereSuffolk County
Single-family detached homesabout 93%about 80%
Owner-occupiedabout 94%about 82%
Median home valueabout $678,000about $578,000
Built before 1960about 31%about 31%
Homes per square mile970–
Most common soilRiverhead and Haven soils, graded (0–8% slopes): regraded loam over sand and gravel (47% of land)
Land on 8%+ slopes8%
Soil with a seasonal water table within ~3 ft0%
Land in a FEMA flood zonenone found in our sample
Public water supplierSuffolk County Water Authority (81%), Greenlawn Water District (17%)
Pool permits fromTown of Smithtown Building Department, (631) 360-7520

One hamlet, two codes

Commack doesn’t issue permits itself; it’s a hamlet, and it straddles a town line. The part east of the line is in the Town of Smithtown; the part west is in the Town of Huntington. Same school district, same mailing address style, different pool codes. Your tax bill tells you which applies.

Commack’s housing is mostly single-family: about 93% detached and about 94% owner-occupied, with a median build year of 1964 and roughly 970 homes per square mile of land (Census ACS 2020–2024 and the 2024 Gazetteer), which works out to about 28,700 square feet of land per home spread evenly.

If you’re on the Smithtown side

  • A complete set of drawings to the Chief Building Inspector: exact pool location, zoning district rules, fence construction, water supply, drainage and disposal.
  • All pool water stays on your land; the plans have to show how it’s kept off neighbors and the street.
  • A permanent barrier to the state code, a temporary fence during construction, and for aboveground pools with a barrier on top of the wall, a property fence too.

If you’re on the Huntington side

  • A permit for inground and aboveground pools; plans showing lot lines, fence, drainage and disposal.
  • A barrier at least 4 feet with self-closing gates and child-proof locks.
  • A neighbor’s fence counts only with notarized consent on file; corner lots keep the pool in the rear yard; lights shielded.
  • Pool area isn’t counted toward lot coverage.

Either way, prices aren’t set by town line. Full codes: the Smithtown and Huntington pool permit guides.

Easy ground, two water suppliers

For a pool, Commack’s ground is forgiving. About 47% of the hamlet is mapped by the USDA as graded Riverhead and Haven soils and another 12% as Haven loam: deep, well-drained loam over sand and gravel. Only about 8% of the land is on slopes of 8% or more, the survey lists no seasonal water table within about 3 feet anywhere we sampled, and there’s no FEMA flood zone in the hamlet. About 9% is cut and fill land from when the subdivisions were graded, so a soil check is worth it if your yard was built up.

That makes Commack a good fit for a standard vinyl or gunite rectangle; the cost variables are access and the patio, not the hole. On the Smithtown side, the “all water stays on your lot” rule means the plans need a dry well or a graded area for backwash and drain-down (pool drainage and dry wells).

Water: the Suffolk County Water Authority covers about 81% of Commack’s land on EPA’s map and the Greenlawn Water District about 17%, on the Huntington side.

Soils mapped in Commack (USDA soil survey). Look up your own lot.
SoilShare of landWhat it isSeasonal water table
Riverhead and Haven soils, graded (0–8% slopes)47%regraded loam over sand and graveldeeper or not rated
Haven loam (0–2% slopes)12%deep, well-drained loam over sand and graveldeeper or not rated
Riverhead sandy loam (3–8% slopes)9%deep, well-drained sandy loam over sand and graveldeeper or not rated
Cut and fill land, gently sloping9%regraded or filled ground; ask for a soil checkdeeper or not rated

Guides for Commack homeowners

Commack pool questions

How do I know if my Commack house is in Smithtown or Huntington?

Your property tax bill names the town. The town also issues your building permits, so a quick call to either building department with your address settles it.

Which town's pool rules are stricter in Commack?

They're strict about different things. Smithtown requires all pool water to be disposed of on your own lot and a property fence even around an aboveground pool with a built-in barrier. Huntington requires child-proof locks on gates and a notarized consent if a neighbor's fence forms part of your barrier, and keeps corner-lot pools in the rear yard.

What does a pool cost in Commack?

Published Long Island prices: $35,000 – $100,000 for vinyl liner, $45,000 – $120,000 for fiberglass and $60,000 – $250,000 for gunite.

Is Commack good ground for an inground pool?

Mostly, yes. About 59% of the hamlet is deep, well-drained Riverhead and Haven soils (USDA soil survey), slopes are gentle on most lots, no seasonal water table showed up within about 3 feet in our sample, and there's no FEMA flood zone.

Sources

  1. U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024 5-year: Commack and Suffolk County housing tables
  2. USDA NRCS, Soil Survey Geographic Database (SSURGO) via Soil Data Access
  3. USDA NRCS Web Soil Survey (look up your own lot)
  4. FEMA Flood Map Service Center, National Flood Hazard Layer
  5. U.S. EPA, Community Water System Service Area Boundaries
  6. Town of Smithtown Code Ch. 252, Swimming Pools
  7. Town of Smithtown Code § 322-17, Swimming pools
  8. Town of Huntington Code Ch. 87, Art. XI, Outdoor Water Pools

Get a written pool price in Commack

Tell us your town and the project. A licensed, independent Long Island pool company calls you back and gives you the price before any work starts. Free to ask, no obligation.

Get a free quote Call (631) 856-2404
  • No fee to you
  • Price in writing first
Call (631) 856-2404 Get a quote