West Islip site check: homes, soil, flood zones and water
| West Islip | Here | Suffolk County |
|---|---|---|
| Single-family detached homes | about 96% | about 80% |
| Owner-occupied | about 95% | about 82% |
| Median home value | about $614,000 | about $578,000 |
| Built before 1960 | about 49% | about 31% |
| Homes per square mile | 1,412 | – |
| Most common soil | Riverhead and Haven soils, graded (0–8% slopes): regraded loam over sand and gravel (32% of land) | |
| Land on 8%+ slopes | 0% | |
| Soil with a seasonal water table within ~3 ft | 4% | |
| Land in a FEMA flood zone | 7% (AE 7%) | |
| Public water supplier | Suffolk County Water Authority (100%) | |
| Pool permits from | Town of Islip Building Division (Department of Planning & Development), (631) 224-5466 | |
West Islip by the numbers
About 96% of West Islip homes are single-family detached and about 95% are owner-occupied, among the highest shares in Suffolk on this site. About half predate 1960 (median build year 1960), and the median value is around $614,000 (Census ACS 2020–2024). At about 1,412 homes per square mile, there’s roughly 19,700 square feet of land per home spread evenly.
Same street name, different setback
| Town of Islip | Town of Babylon | |
|---|---|---|
| Side and rear setback | 10–25 ft by district | 6 ft |
| Fence | 4–6 ft high, at least 4 ft from the pool | 4 ft, openings under 4 in |
| Equipment | 6 ft from side and rear lines | per plans |
| Abandoned pool | fill, restore grade, notify inspector | fill voids, demolition permit to regrade |
On a 60-by-100-foot lot, the difference between a 6-foot and an 18-foot setback is the difference between a 16-by-32 pool fitting or not.
Find the cesspool first
West Islip is one of the hamlets in the county’s sewer-extension study, which means most homes still rely on an on-site cesspool or septic system. The pool, patio and equipment can’t go over it, and digging near it can trigger a sanitary repair.
Published Long Island prices: vinyl $35,000 – $100,000, gunite $60,000 – $250,000.
West Islip’s ground and the bay
West Islip is flat and mostly well drained: the USDA soil survey maps about 53% of the hamlet as graded Riverhead and Haven soils and Riverhead sandy loam, with about 17% cut and fill land and 8% loose Plymouth sand. Only about 4% of the land has a seasonal water table within about 3 feet.
About 7% of West Islip’s land is in a FEMA AE flood zone in our sample, with base flood elevations of 4 to 7 feet south of Montauk Highway along the bay and canals. Those lots need groundwater control in the quote and an equipment pad above the flood elevation. Elsewhere in the hamlet, the cesspool location and the Islip-or-Babylon setback decide the layout more than the soil does. Water comes from the Suffolk County Water Authority.
Before you call builders
Find the cesspool on your survey, confirm whether your street is Islip or Babylon, and read how big a pool fits your lot. If your yard already has an old pool, compare a new liner with starting over.
| Soil | Share of land | What it is | Seasonal water table |
|---|---|---|---|
| Riverhead and Haven soils, graded (0–8% slopes) | 32% | regraded loam over sand and gravel | deeper or not rated |
| Riverhead sandy loam (0–3% slopes) | 21% | deep, well-drained sandy loam over sand and gravel | deeper or not rated |
| Cut and fill land, gently sloping | 17% | regraded or filled ground; ask for a soil check | deeper or not rated |
| Plymouth loamy coarse sand (0–3% slopes) | 8% | loose, excessively drained coarse sand | deeper or not rated |
West Islip pool questions
Is West Islip in the Town of Islip or Babylon?
Mostly the Town of Islip, with a part in the Town of Babylon. Your tax bill names the town, and that town's Building Division issues the pool permit.
Is West Islip on sewers?
Much of it isn't sewered today. A Suffolk County feasibility study has looked at extending the Southwest Sewer District to West Islip, along with Deer Park, North Babylon, West Babylon, Wyandanch and Wheatley Heights. Until then, the cesspool or septic system is in the yard and has to be located before a pool is placed.
How close to the property line can a West Islip pool be?
In the Town of Islip, 10 feet in most districts, 14 in Residence A, 18 in AA and AAA, and 25 in BAA. In the Town of Babylon, 6 feet from side and rear lines.
Is West Islip in a flood zone?
About 7% of the hamlet's land is in a FEMA AE zone in our sample (base flood elevations 4 to 7 feet), along the bay and canals south of Montauk Highway.
Sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024 5-year: West Islip and Suffolk County housing tables
- USDA NRCS, Soil Survey Geographic Database (SSURGO) via Soil Data Access
- USDA NRCS Web Soil Survey (look up your own lot)
- FEMA Flood Map Service Center, National Flood Hazard Layer
- U.S. EPA, Community Water System Service Area Boundaries
- Town of Islip Code Art. XXVIII, Swimming Pools (eCode360)
- Town of Islip Building Division
- Patch: Suffolk sewer feasibility study for Deer Park, North Babylon, West Babylon, Wyandanch, Wheatley Heights and West Islip